Security Research Review

 Bharat Rakshak > Security Research Review > In Memoriam


2004: The Year in Review

Laxman Bahroo, Sunil S and Airavat Singh  

Warning!

This page contains graphic images of violence that may be unsuitable for viewers below a certain age. Viewer discretion is strongly advised. 

Infamy in September: A three day hostage crisis at a school in Northern Ossetia province of Russia by terrorists resulted in the carnage that claimed the lives of nearly 1,000 people many of them children. The inconsolable residents of the city turned to spirituality while the government took stock of the situation. Prime Minister Putin echoed the shortcomings and vowed to revamp the security. Aggressive Russian posture in the region could alter the precarious balance between Russia and its former republics.

 

Image Source: CBS, AP

3/11?: On March 11, 2004 multiple coordinated bombings killed nearly 200 and injured over a 1,000 rail commuters in Madrid, Spain. Initial confusion about the origin of the attack blamed ETA (Basque separatists) only later to back track and blame Al Qaeda. The bombing led to a public outcry and an electoral loss for Prime Minister Aznar previously favored to win. Instead the shock of the bombing favored the Socialist party candidate Mr. Zapatero who favored disengagement from Iraq. Were the consequences of the bombing calculated or serendipitous? ABC News Reuters

 

Image Source: ABC News Reuters

Tightening the Noose: The Maoist insurgency is a growing thorn in the side of the Nepali government. In the past year they have begun a slow assault on the capital, Phase 4, the final phase in their insurgency. Nepal lurches from showdown between the military and the insurgents punctuated by calls for talks. In late December 2004, Katmandu resident faced a second blockade of the valley’s highways leading to panic and hoarding. The crisis resulted in renewed calls for negotiations.

 

Image Source: STR/AFP/Getty Images 

Looming Storm: The Islamists and their allies in Bangladesh's military are now becoming increasingly assertive. These people are closely tied to Islamist groups in Pakistan, and view Prime Minister Khalida Zia as being somewhat more “friendly” towards their brand of politics. They also view Madame Hasina, the leader of the Awami league, and daughter of the Sheikh Mujibur Rehman, the founder of Bangladesh as close to India. The photo depicts the aftermath of a stunning grenade attack that nearly killed Madame Hasina and several of her top advisors in Dhaka. Though no group claimed responsibility - the finger of blame pointed quite naturally towards the increasingly militarized Islamists. Persistent rumors in the international press of the presence of Al Qaida members in Bangladesh did little to calm frayed nerves.

 

Image Source: http://www.despardes.com/

Transition: Prime Minister Vajpayee greets his successor Prime Minister Manmohan Singh after the NDA suffered an unexpected loss in the elections. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, former Finance Minister under the Prime Minister Rao administration ushers in speculation that economic reform will be given even greater importance during his tenure.

 

Image Source: Prakash Singh /AFP/Getty Images

 

Sports Fans: In continuation of former PM Vajpayee’s hand of friendship to Pakistan, the Indian cricket team toured that country after a gap of 14 years. The tour came as a surprise to many, especially as other nations had refused to play in Pakistan citing security reasons. The government of Pakistan sent mixed messages by organizing unprecedented security for the Indian players and welcoming Indian fans; but then also choosing to conduct a missile test just a day before the arrival of the Indian team. The Pakistani people on the other hand welcomed the touring team and treated Indian fans very hospitably. The sporting clash turned out the best overseas result since 1986 for Indian cricket with the team winning the test series 3-2 and the one-day series 2-1. Saurav Ganguly became India’s most successful captain.   

 

Image Source: AP Photo KM Chaudhary 

Connections: As terrorist violence continued unabated the army put in place electronic surveillance equipment to hunt out the infiltrators. In a sign of growing confidence the government reduced the military presence in the state and delivered an economic package while Chief Minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed said that J&K was safe in secular India's hands. As the power-hungry state waited for the completion of numerous hydel-power, projects cell phone coverage increased exponentially with private players also entering the growing market. The Jammu-Udhampur railway line was completed and began operations igniting hopes for its extension into the valley."  

Image Source: The Daily Excelsior Sunday Magazine 

 

Ballot box: Despite high security precautions and threats, Afghans voted for their favorite candidates. The vote was a strike against violence of proposed by the resurgent Taliban. Curiously, the numerous threats of violence directed at voters did not materialize except for a few instances. Wheather the electoral process unites Afghan under one nation or leads to further division is speculative. Election posturing though designed to energize a voter base must not be taken for policy. Afghan leader have the unenviable task of ruling a disparate population that often expresses its politics from the barrel of a gun.

Image Source: Ahmad Masood/Reuters Yahoo 

Unveiled: Masooda Jalal, the only female candidate to run in the Afghan Presidential race. She is a testament to the journey of Afghan women in the post Taliban era. Historically, women held numerous posts in the pre Afghan Jihad era. Their social position reached a nadir with increasing restrictions by the Taliban, often bordering on the ridiculous. Masooda Jalal depicts how much they have achieved and how much they have yet to achieve.

Image Source: AFP/Emmanuel Dunand, Yahoo  

Fundamental Differences: 2004 was the year of the election, the American Presidential election and its accompanying debates drew sharp differences between the two candidates and their vision of the world. The issues dividing Blue from Red included Abortion, Gay marriages, Iraq, terrorism and the economy. The debates both public and private were among the most acrimonious in recent memory.

 

Image Source: Jeff Haynes /AFP/Getty Images October 13, 2004 

Realpolitik: American forces in Afghanistan were faced with the difficult task of pacifying the Pashtun belt. As a start to this process they raided Al Qaida and Taliban positions in the Shah-i-Kot area. The Al Qaida fighters fled into Pakistan and took refuge in Wana. Nek Mohammed, the leader of the Yargulkhai branch of the Ahmedzai Wazir tribe was close to several Al Qaida and Taliban leaders. Nek and sympathetic elements of the Pakistan Army worked through the auspices of two newly formed groups, the Jaishul al-Qiba al-Jihadi al-Siri al-Alami and Jundullah to provide fleeing Al Qaida with regrouping facilities. The Pakistan Army citing "general lawlessness in the frontier regions" attempted to ignore this activity. However under tremendous pressure from the US after the murder of 18 American soldiers in Shah-i-Kot, the Pakistanis carried out a "major operation" against Nek Mohammed's groups. This half-hearted operation quite predictably failed to do anything meaningful and inflamed tribal sentiments. The Pakistanis used the conflagration as a excuse to hold a Jirga and sign a ceasefire with Nek Mohammed's group. In exchange for the ceasefire, Nek Mohammed agreed to stop all attacks on the Pakistan Army. In this photo Lt. Gen. Safdar Hussain is seen meeting Nek Muhammad, at the Tribal Jirga in Shakhai. Brig.(r) Mahmood Shah Secretary FATA (Security) looks on in the center. The photo summarizes the strain of duplicity inherent in all Pakistani Army dealings on the issue of domestic support for Al Qaida terrorists in Wana. Readers may note that soon after this event, according to rumor the Americans tired of duplicity killed Nek Mohammed in an airstrike. The Pakistani Army quickly claimed credit for this, and paid the price for it. A few days later the Karachi Corps Commander Lt. Ahsan Saleem Hayat's convoy was challenged in the high-security zone of Karachi city. The commander survived the attempt but the aura of superiority the Pakistan Army carries about itself in Pakistan was considerably damaged.

 

Image Source: Tariq Mahmood/AFP/Getty Images  

Staged: This photo shows a large cache of arms captured by the "Pakistan Army" from the Al Qaida sympathizers in the Wana area. A trained eye can spot the distinctive camouflage patterns of the troops in the photo and the SSG flashes on the men in khaki. This is most likely a seizure by the joint Special Operations Task Force comprising the US SOF and the Pakistan Army. The equipment appears to include all sorts of high-tech material. The presence of such equipment in the middle of the "lawless, underdeveloped, impenetrable tribal belt" of Pakistan, where there is no electricity, roads etc... is baffling to most observers. A skeptical mind could be forgiving for believing that the equipment displayed here was purchased in Karachi and planted in Wana for a simulated success. Such a theory, though speculative would offer a satisfying explanation for the continued use of Wana by Al Qaida and resurgent Taliban groups for operations against the US in Afghanistan.

 

 Image Source: STR/AFP/Getty Images

Blowback: A picture of a burnt out Pakistan Army truck near Wana. This is somehow the most accurate image to come out the region. The truck is witness to a furious ambush that killed its occupants. As the list of posthumous award winners on Pakistan's Army Day grows, images like these tell the real story of their exploits. The ham-fisted operations of the Pakistan Army are most likely producing sizable civilian casualties and inducing revolts by local tribes. While at a strategic level this may successfully convince the Americans that the Musharraf regime cannot actually stamp its authority on the Tribal belt and that any attempt to dislodge Al-Qaida from Wana would result in terrible consequences for Musharraf - the immediate consequences of any strategy of deliberate provocation of the tribals are likely to be borne by under equipped Pakistani soldiers in the region. This picture bears testimony to the fact that the Pakistan Army though exceptional at creating other peoples' terrorists is quite incompetent at fighting them on its own soil.

 

Image Source: Nor Mohammad /AFP/Getty Images  

Birds of a Feather: The death of the charismatic Nek Mohammed created a vacuum in the media. This was quickly filled by Abdullah Mahsud, a recently released inmate of Guantanmo Bay, who took up terrorism the instant he touched Pakistani soil. One of the first acts he committed was to kidnap Chinese engineers working on the Gomal Zam Dam project. It is commonly held among analysts that these "engineers" are most likely PRC intelligence officials keeping tabs on US activity in the region. The kidnap saga was given considerable press coverage and the PRC emissaries in Islamabad began to put pressure on Gen. Musharraf to resolve the crisis in favor of China. Soon afterwards the Pakistan Army's SSG conducted a high profile operation where they tried to rescue the Chinese engineers and killed one of the hostages in the process. This photo released soon after the operation had most Pakistan watchers wondering that given the abundance of shalwar-kameez's and balaclava caps in this photo; how did the SSG assault team distinguish between each other, the hostages and the terrorists. Incidentally the Pakistan Army also initially claimed they had killed Mahsud, but then he mysteriously reappeared elsewhere, by which point most Pakistan watchers were rolling their eyes.

 

Image Source: Reuters/Stringer October 14, 2004

Zealot: Maulana Nizamuddin Shamzai,éminence grise of Jamia ul Uloom Banuri Town, heir to the legacy of the late Maulana Mohammad Yousaf Ludhianvi, head of the Majlis-e-Tawwun-e-Islami, spiritual godfather to the Jaish-e-Mohammad and the Harkat-ul-Mujaheddin, was shot to death outside his office in Karachi. Maulana Shamzai considered the most respected Sunni Deobandi cleric in Pakistan after Maulana Rafiuddin Usmani of the Pakistani Government's Council for Islamic Ideology, was revered by the people across the globe that took his revisionist and exhibitionist version of Islam seriously. While there can no doubt of the late Maulana's scholarship, his uncompromising stand on sectarian issues and on support for the Taliban and Osama Bin Laden had made him many enemies in America and Pakistan. The Maulana had made several attempts to communicate with western observers however the gap was becoming increasingly unbridgeable. In the picture we see Maulana Iskander, the rector of Jamia Binuri, offering prayers at his funeral. The killing of Maulana Shamzai showcases an internal coupling of Pakistan's establishment supported Jihads. The Jihadis so-beloved to the Pakistan Army, are almost always uncompromising Sunni fundamentalists like Shamzai. Whenever the US pressurizes the Pakistan Army into giving way on terrorism issues, the Sunni groups take out their wrath on the Shia minority in Pakistan. Pretty soon a high profile Sunni cleric turns up dead - and the Shias are blamed again feeding a cycle of violence. 

 

 Image Source: http://www.liputan6.com/ 

Strife among the Faithful: As stated earlier, the slightest opportunity to blame the Shias offers the numerically Sunni groups a cause to riot or worse target Shia imambargahs with suicide attacks. If ever a Shia officer of the Pakistan Army is involved in any American anti-terrorist raid in Pakistan, his qaum (community) is automatically targeted in response to that. The result is responsive rioting by the Shias and pretty soon a cycle takes hold. Such cycles coupled with the "madrassization" of the education system in Pakistan breed fanaticism and that for the most part feeds the ranks of the Al Qaida's allies in Pakistan. In this photo we see Shia mourners at the funeral of one of the worst suicide bombings of a Shia Imambargah.

 

Image Source: Yahoo, AP Photo/K.M.Chaudary  

Carnage: Several powerful bombs simultaneously ripped through Assam and Nagaland on the 2nd of October killing over 69 people and injuring hundreds of others. The bombings timed with the birth anniversary of the apostle of peace, Mahatma Gandhi, and may have been aimed at sabotaging the peace talks between the government of India and the National Socialist Council of Nagaland (IM). Those talks however were successfully held and the NSCN(IM) condemned the gruesome bombings. The police suspected the hand of the United Liberation Front of Asom (ULFA) and the National Democratic Front of Bodoland (NDFB) in the terrorist attacks.

Image Source: AFP Yahoo  

Rage: One of the most shocking and telling scenes from Iraq. In April 2004 a burst of anger directed against representatives of western businesses. Four contractors were beaten, killed and the burnt corpses were mutilated by a youthful jubilant mob. World audiences recoiled in horror at the actions of a “liberated” people.

Image Source: Sabah Arar/AFP/Getty Images March 31, 2004   

   

Nefarious: Abu Musab al Zarqawi the notorious terrorist with Jordanian roots and the so called Emir of Al Qaeda operations quickly rose to fame in June 2004 after beheading an American contractor Nick Berg. The subsequent beheadings of international workers in Iraq chilled a sheltered audience and brought the war in Iraq into the hearts and minds of the world.  

Image Source: Reuters/TV Al Arabiya via Reuters Television

India’s End of an Era: Former Prime Minister Rao’s sudden death shocked India and an outpouring of grief and fond memories emerged from an indebted nation. During his tenure as Prime Minister, his steady hand guided India thru the early Post Cold War uncertainty, economic instability and internal upheavals. Many of today’s successes such as a booming economy, burgeoning confidence, and engagement of the world can be attributed to his farsighted vision. Prime Minister Rao’s decided measures during difficult times set the stage for a rising India.  

Image Source:AFP Yahoo  

 

 

 America’s End of an Era: Former President Reagan succumbed to a decade long battle with Alzheimer’s disease. President Reagan’s tenure was marked by skyrocketing brinkmanship and ground breaking peace. Engagement of the Soviet Union thru brinkmanship and peacemaking helped to ease the world out of Cold War without threatened nuclear annihilation. President Reagan’s steely resolve will serve as an example for future generations.  

Image Source:Reuters/Peter Jones  

 

 Grief: 2004 was a tragic year for Ismail Khan, Emir of Herat. Earlier in the year, his son, Mirwaiz Sadiq (Minister of Aviation) was killed under suspicious circumstances while investigating a failed assassination attempt on his father’s life. Several days of attacks between Ismail Khan’s forces and Afghan National Army forced Kabul to deploy further troops in the region. As the year progressed, Ismail Khan forces were attacked and forced to retreat as Amanullah Khan, a rival Pashtun warlord attacked the border region. The tragedy culminated as he was removed from his Governorship by President Karzai at the inception of election campaign. 

Image Source: AP Photo Ihlas News Agency   

Passing the Torch: The Chairman of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, Yasser Arafat passed away on the 11th of November at the age of 75. The Head of the Palestinian Authority had been hospitalized at Paris for the last few days. Yasser Arafat founded the Al-Fatah movement and began a violent struggle against “Zionism”, later becoming the Chairman of the PLO. He eventually recognized the state of Israel and began working towards establishing a state for the Palestinians before death intervened. Chairman Arafat was given a state funeral at Cairo in Egypt. While alive he symbolized Palestinian resistance in death he may become a symbol of Palestinian statehood. Mahmoud Abbas ponders the future while a portrait of Chairman Arafat dominates the background.

Image Source: Reuters/Ammar Awad  

 

Hands across Asia: Bangladesh India Myanmar Sri Lanka Thailand Economic Cooperation expanded to include Nepal and Bhutan. Furthermore, the organization was renamed Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation with a pledge towards establishing a Free Trade agreement. The organization focuses on tourism, people to people contacts, energy and infrastructure cooperation. The Tran regional group bridges the economic potential of Indian subcontinent with the dynamic Southeast Asia.

Image Source: Getty Images Kittiwongsakul / AFP  

 October Surprise: In a stunning move the Junta expelled one of its top leaders, Lt General Khin Nyunt, wore many hats as Prime Minister and head if Military Intelligence. His downfall was mare more shocking as he was widely speculated to be the next leader of Myanmar. The Junta in a coordinated move placed Lt General Nyunt under house arrest citing health reasons and arrested his top supporters in Military intelligence. Myanmar watchers predicted further clamp downs and economic roll backs but the only certainty is that Myanmar’s regime is unpredictable.

Image Source: AFP File/Hoang Dinh Nam  

 

 

 Tragedy: On the 26th of December, at 6:29 am IST, an earthquake measuring 9 on the Richter Scale hit the seabed off the coast of Sumatra, Indonesia. It generated a massive Tsunami tidal wave, which within minutes swamped the Indonesian province of Aceh and India's Andaman & Nicobar Islands. In a short two-and-a-half hours later the towering wave neared the coast of India, Sri Lanka and the Maldives decimating up to kilometer of habitation. A failure of communication compounded the catastrophe resulting in greater devastation and loss of life. India was the first country to organize rescue and relief efforts despite personal loss. The Indian Armed Forces pledged hardware and personnel and took a lead role in the entire Indian Ocean region. The enormous tragedy compelled other governments to join the relief effort and promise aid. Money was promptly raised by individuals and charities across the world to assuage the families of the hundreds of thousands who died in this tragedy. The satellite image starkly depicts the effects of the worst natural calamity in human history.

Image Source: AP Photo/Space Imaging Yahoo


© 2005 Bharat-Rakshak